McCain Announces Sarah Palin as VP Choice, Who?

Posted by John Publius Jr. on August 31st, 2008 — in Opinion Polls - VOTE!, John McCain, Blog

In a surprising move on Friday, John McCain announced that his running mate is Republican Alaska Governor Sarah Palin. The most remarkable election year in generations became even more interesting.

What impact will the selection of Sarah Palin have?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

McCain’s Palin announcement was a successful media coup to change the story headlines quickly. Apparently, the McCain campaign agreed with many people in thinking that Barack Obama gave a sensational speech on Thursday to cap off a highly energized and united Democratic Party Convention. One day later, media attention understandably focused on the first female Republican nominee for the Vice-Presidency.

This tactic certainly worked on me. As an amateur blogger, I have unfortunately little time to devote to this blog. I try to address the big issues as they arise, and the Palin nomination is certainly important and historic. Consequently, I am delaying my post on the Democratic Convention briefly, even though this story is also very big news.

Sarah Palin is NOT well-known. We have learned she has been governor of Alaska since 2006, and before that Palin was mayor of Wasilla (population of less than 10,000). She also was runner-up in the Miss Alaska contest of 1984. Palin is 44 years old, has a lifetime membership in the National Rifle Association (NRA), and enjoys mooseburgers. Her social politics: she wants to outlaw ALL abortions and opposes gay marriage. She was FOR Alaska’s “bridge to nowhere” before she was AGAINST it. Like John McCain, Sarah Palin embraces the maverick label, although critics argue that both McCain and Palin support virtually all of the same policies as George Bush.

Immediately upon her selection as running mate, media voices on the left denounced her and those on the right praised her.

Many Democrats criticize McCain’s choice of Sarah Palin as a gimmick and a clumsy attempt to win over disgruntled supporters of Hillary Clinton. They characterize Palin as a “lightweight” given her very limited relevant governmental experience. Many Democrats strongly question Palin’s ability to be an effective President of the United States, which of course is the primary requirement for a Vice-President. McCain’s advanced age (72) and past health problems increase the chances that Palin would need to step into the presidency. Some argue that the Palin nomination is insulting to women because McCain passed over other female Republican officials who are much better suited for the role (e.g., Christine Todd Whitman). 

The selection of Sarah Palin energized the John McCain campaign really for the first time. Many Republicans are celebrating the Palin choice for several reasons. Many believe Governor Palin represents the true core conservative principles while also being a Washington outsider and maverick. “Culturally”, Palin reflects the “true American values” and lifestyle of Main Street USA - who doesn’t love mooseburgers? Republicans now are showing much more enthusiasm for John McCain because they believe the Palin nomination proves that McCain is a bold leader with vision. Sarah Palin helps to unite and motivate the Republican base. Furthermore, some argue the choice is “tactically brilliant” because the McCain/Palin ticket offers Republicans a solid ability to win over more undecided women, especially the Hillary Clinton supporters who have resisted jumping on the Barack Obama bandwagon. Sarah Palin may also appeal to younger voters, and her selection shows that John McCain is also ready to “pass the torch” to a new generation.

Like most voters, I am still trying to figure out “who is Sarah Palin”? I am happy that John McCain chose a woman. We are long overdue to break the glass ceiling that has blocked woman and non-whites from attaining the highest levels of power. I worry that Palin’s policy positions continue the same old George Bush ideology that has devastated our economy, harmed our international standing, and unnecessarily divided us at a time when we especially need to come together. But we will see - I never really thought about Sarah Palin until Friday.

Republicans have criticized Barack Obama for “lack of experience”, but the Palin selection removes this as a credible argument against Obama. The “founding fathers”, the framers of the Constitution wanted all elected officials to be ordinary citizens as opposed to creating a professional leadership class. The world is more complicated now and our leaders may need a bit more experience than in the 18th century. Nevertheless, the principle still applies. We are better off electing people with wise judgment, who communicate well, have a vision for our future, and who will enact effective policies. The alternative is to elect only technocrats (who are more helpful “behind the scenes”), or even worse, for members of an elite class to continually hold power.

The selection of Sarah Palin is an important breakthrough in U.S. politics. This choice likely demonstrates that the McCain campaign is worried about their chances. They probably felt they needed to make a dramatic and exciting move to change the dynamics of the presidential race. But more importantly, I am hearing two iconic 1960’s songs in my head. Buffalo Springfield’s song “For What It’s Worth”, with the famous lyrics, “there’s something happening here, what it is ain’t exactly clear”. And Bob Dylan’s “The Times They Are A-Changing”. When even the Republicans see a need to open up the halls of government, to break glass ceilings, we must acknowledge that this is a “change year”. Whether the Palin selection is a good or bad choice, politically pandering or not, the election of 2008 has already changed the American political landscape. Sarah Palin is the latest example. One day earlier, Barack Obama’s speech before a record crowd of 84,000 at Denver’s Mile High Stadium was another dramatic highlight in an amazing year of historic news. In 2008 we are finally recording a new soundtrack.

Sphere: Related Content

Opinion Poll: Libertarian, Green, Ralph Nader in 2008

Posted by John Publius Jr. on May 26th, 2008 — in Green Party, Bob Barr, Libertarian Party, Ralph Nader, 3rd Party Politics, Opinion Polls - VOTE!, Blog

Will Libertarian Party presidential candidate Bob Barr have a real impact in the 2008 general election?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Will the Green Party’s presidential candidate have a real impact in the 2008 general election?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Will presidential candidate Ralph Nader have a real impact in the 2008 general election?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Media coverage of third party candidates is:

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Check out our previous post Third Parties in U.S. Politics: Libertarians, Greens, Nader.

Sphere: Related Content

Will Obama win the white working-class vote in November?

Posted by John Publius Jr. on May 13th, 2008 — in Opinion Polls - VOTE!, Barack Obama, Blog

Will all Democratics vote for Obama in November?
I don’t mean literally “all Democrats”. Even Obama Girl was too busy to cast her vote for Obama on election day. I mean “all Democrats” in the sense that John Kerry and Al Gore received overwhelming vote totals from people who usually vote Democrat.

Yes, I think Barack Obama will unite the Democratic Party voters. Only a small percentage of people who voted for John Kerry and/or Al Gore will not vote for Obama. These few will either vote for John McCain or just not vote. Of course, to become the next president, Obama must exceed the vote totals Gore and Kerry achieved. 

Will Obama win overwhelming support among Democratic voters in November?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

The Democratic Party leadership certainly will unite behind Obama, and most Democratic voters will also vote for Obama in November. Obama also must win over overwhelming support from people who voted for Hillary Clinton. Recent polls show that this may be a challenge. However, the general election is more than five months away. Obama and the Democratic Party need to consolidate the Democratic base and expand it. The electoral map has been relatively static in recent elections. The Democrats need to change the map to include a few more states while maintaining their hold on previously-won states.

Read the rest of this entry »

Sphere: Related Content

Obama/Clinton Dream Ticket? Vote in Our Opinion Polls

Posted by John Publius Jr. on May 8th, 2008 — in Opinion Polls - VOTE!, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, Blog

Vote in our polls and keep posting your insightful comments!

Inform your friends about this website. I hope this is an inviting forum where people feel comfortable to “agree to disagree” while discussing very important issues.

Obama/Clinton ticket: will it happen?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Will Obama ask Clinton to be his running mate?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

If Obama asks Clinton to be his running mate, will she do it?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Is an Obama/Clinton ticket the best choice for Obama victory in Nov. 2008?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …
Sphere: Related Content

News Media Finally Covers A Real Issue: Gas Prices

Posted by John Publius Jr. on May 6th, 2008 — in Opinion Polls - VOTE!, Issues/Policy, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, John McCain, Mainstream Media, Blog

Just when I thought the Democratic Party nomination would only be a referendum on bowling vs. basketball, finally the media is covering a real issue: gasoline prices.

Gas prices impact most people much more than candidate flag pin accessory decisions. It is encouraging that we can analyze a real issue.

Hillary Clinton has joined John McCain in calling for a “gas tax holiday”, proposing a suspension of the federal tax of 18 cents per gallon of gasoline during the summer months. Many analysts and Barack Obama have heavily criticized this proposal. They claim that this “gas tax holiday” would have little economic benefit and encourage more gas consumption when our energy policy should instead focus on conserving oil and other energy resources. Clinton critics also decry this proposal as nothing more than political pandering. (Steve Brenan’s article is one example. If you can find someone praising the proposal, please post it in the comments - I always want to present “both sides”). Clinton has dismissed her critics as simply “elite opinion”.

For many people, a temporary elimination of the federal gas tax will not add up to meaningful savings. However, most people whose income depends on significant driving would welcome this relief.

What do you think of the proposed “temporary federal gas tax holiday”?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

The “gas tax holiday” proposal is not a major issue, but it opens the discussion to a critically important one: U.S. energy policy. Everyone should know about the “peak oil” debate.

The candidates actually have much more substance than the goofy nonsense that dominates the media coverage.

Remarkably, unlike the websites for the Democrats, the “issues” section of John McCain’s website does NOT include “energy policy” as one of his issues. It does list “Second Amendment” (guns) as one of the major issues. I really try to be objective, but WOW!

Sphere: Related Content

Stephen Colbert Debates the Issue of Electability

Posted by John Publius Jr. on May 2nd, 2008 — in Comic Relief, Opinion Polls - VOTE!, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, John McCain, Blog

As the Democratic Party moves towards finally choosing its 2008 presidential nominee, the issue of “electability” is central, especially for the remaining undecided super delegates. Both Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama have strengths, weaknesses, and very similar positions on the main policy issues. The Democrats want to choose the candidate who has the best chance to defeat John McCain in the general election on November 4th.

As often is the case, after reading many articles, listening to talk radio, and watching TV news shows of the serious pundits, I find that comedy shows have as much insight and needed perspective.

I enjoy this video of Stephen Colbert debating with himself on the question of electability.

Which Democratic candidate has the best chance to defeat John McCain?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …
Sphere: Related Content

Vote in Our Opinion Polls on Rev. Wright controversy

Posted by John Publius Jr. on March 19th, 2008 — in Rev. Wright controversy, Opinion Polls - VOTE!, Barack Obama, Blog

Election Referee exists to focus attention on election controversies. The Rev. Wright controversy strikes me as a major issue. I will move on to other important election issues soon. This controversy likely will be a recurring theme on this website.

I am very interested in your opinions on the Wright controversy (and all issues)!

Please vote in our polls - it is anonymous. Of course, also continue posting your insightful comments. I’m very impressed with the intelligent dialogue, please keep posting more!

Inform your friends about this website. It would be nice to have more people voting and posting comments. I hope this is an inviting forum where people feel comfortable to “agree to disagree” while discussing very important issues.

The Rev. Wright controversy changes my opinion on Obama:

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

Does the Rev. Wright controversy change the dynamics of who will be the Democratic Party’s nominee?

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

If Obama is the Democratic candidate vs. McCain, this controversy:

View Results

Loading ... Loading …

This Election Referee website’s opinion on the Rev. Wright controversy is:

View Results

Loading ... Loading …
Sphere: Related Content